Oklahoma Swing, Part 8 - Contango Markets and Their Influence on Cushing Inventories

During the summer of 2018, crude oil inventories at the trading hub in Cushing, OK, dropped to extreme lows. With estimated tank bottoms around 14.6 MMbbl, Cushing stockpiles hit 21.8 MMbbl for the week of August 3. Traders’ alarm bells were ringing, and upstream and downstream observers were wondering if low storage levels were going to cause significant operational issues. But just when it seemed tanks were nearing catastrophic lows, inventories reversed course and started to climb. Since August, crude stocks have increased by 13.6 MMbbl, or nearly 60%, and there is now talk of potentially too much crude en route to Cushing, maxing out capacity there. There are many contributing factors to this most recent inventory swing, with increased domestic production and the tail end of refinery turnaround season being two of the bigger fundamental drivers. But the main catalyst has been the shift from a backwardated forward curve to a contango forward curve in the WTI futures market. Today, we continue our Cushing series with a snapshot of recent contango markets and the impact those prices have had on stockpiles at the central Oklahoma hub.

Recently, it seems like every time we stop to take a breath, something substantial changes at Cushing. We are now in our eighth blog on Cushing, and since we started the series, multiple new pipelines into and out of the hub have been announced, prompt-month prices have had their largest drop in three years, and crude inventories at the hub have increased by more than half. Throughout the series, we have highlighted connectivity to upstream and downstream markets, crude characteristics at the hub, and most recently, plans for expansions to existing lines out of Cushing. Today, we look at recent changes in the forward curve and what impact it’s having on storage levels in the area.

In our This Place is Empty blog a few months back, we discussed the difference between contango and backwardated WTI markets backwardation is when the future price for WTI is lower than the current prompt-month price; contango occurs when the future price for WTI is higher than the current prompt-month price. Figure 1 shows how the forward curve for WTI at Cushing has shifted over the past five and a half months the colored lines show the forward curve price (y-axis in $/bbl) for the subsequent 29 future months (x-axis) at the first of each month (blue line for June 2018, black line for July 2018, green line for August 2018 etc.) and, in the red line across the bottom of the graph, the forward curve as of November 19, 2018. As you can see, the market was backwardated (forward prices in steady decline) in June, July, August, September and October. But by November 1, the front of the forward curve (orange line) had shifted, putting the market into contango for the first 12 months or so before reverting to backwardation. And as of November 19 (yesterday; red line), the market remained in contango for about a year, with prices holding almost flat thereafter.

To access the remainder of Oklahoma Swing, Part 8 - Contango Markets and Their Influence on Cushing Inventories you must be logged as a RBN Backstage Pass™ subscriber.

Full access to the RBN Energy blog archive which includes any posting more than 5 days old is available only to RBN Backstage Pass™ subscribers. In addition to blog archive access, RBN Backstage Pass™ resources include Drill-Down Reports, Spotlight Reports, Spotcheck Indicators, Market Fundamentals Webcasts, Get-Togethers and more. If you have already purchased a subscription, be sure you are logged in For additional help or information, contact us at info@rbnenergy.com or 888-613-8874.