March’s crude oil price crash hit the E&P sector like a tsunami, shattering capital and operating budgets, upending drilling plans, and eviscerating equity valuations. The initial responses by producers to the price collapse included a flood of capex reductions, corporate belt-tightening, and scattered production shut-ins. But first-quarter earnings reports issued in late April and early May provided the first detailed insight into the financial wreckage the crisis unleashed on U.S. E&Ps. It wasn’t pretty. The plunge in the WTI oil price to $20/bbl at the end of the first quarter triggered a combined $60 billion in impairments of oil and gas reserves across the 41 E&Ps we track, as well as a 16% decline in average revenue per barrel of oil equivalent (boe) from the pre-pandemic fourth quarter of 2019. More trouble may be ahead: the average oil price in the second quarter is on track for a 35% decline from the first quarter, which will dramatically impact the cash flows that allow companies to pay their staff, keep the lights on, and hold creditors at bay. Today, we analyze the first-quarter earnings results of our representative sample of U.S. producers and take a look forward to the potential effect of lower pricing on second-quarter earnings.
Before we dive into the numbers, it’s worth briefly reviewing the cost structure of U.S. E&Ps — a topic outlined in two blogs in April. First, in Eve of Destruction, we analyzed the costs of producing oil and gas, servicing interest on debt, and paying staff and office overhead for the 34 companies in our Oil-Weighted and Diversified E&P peer groups based on 2019 financial statements. Then, in Shelter from the Storm, we did the same with the nine Gas-Weighted E&Ps we follow. In both write-ups, we excluded impairment charges, income taxes, and exploration expenses that tend to be deferred when prices are low. For the Oil-Weighted and Diversified E&Ps, the average total cost was $28.82/boe of oil produced and the average cash cost (excluding depreciation, depletion and amortization costs, or DD&A) was $15.24/boe. Oil and gas companies rely on commodity price realizations in excess of these costs to fund capital expenditures and to return money to shareholders through dividends and share repurchases. We pointed out that steep reductions in capex, dividend cuts, and share repurchase programs were likely as commodity prices fell, with shut-ins of production from higher-cost wells likely if realizations dipped below the breakeven mark.
This thesis seems to have played out already, given the increasing severity of investment and operational reductions announced with first-quarter results. The latest quarterly data showed realizations of Oil-Weighted producers fell 12% to $32.85/boe and realizations of Diversified producers declined 19% to just $27.71/boe, slightly below the year-end 2019 breakeven point. Per-unit revenues of our total 41-company universe, including Gas-Weighted producers, were $25.58/boe, or about 16% lower than the $30.57/boe posted in the fourth quarter of 2019 and the lowest since 2016. Lifting costs came in at $9.65/boe, $0.37/boe below the fourth quarter, primarily because of a $0.27/boe decline in production taxes. DD&A expenses were down $0.03/boe to $11.88/boe. Exploration expenses, which do have some abandonments and unproved property impairments imbedded in that data, more than doubled, to $3.76/boe. Still, our universe of E&Ps reported pre-tax operating profits excluding impairments of only $354 million — barely in the black. The companies generated over $19 billion in cash flow during the first quarter of 2020 (red bar in Figure 1), or just under $16 for each boe produced. That’s lower than the average quarterly cash flow numbers of 2018 and 2019, but higher than those for the 2015-17 period.
To access the remainder of Spring Breakdown - Impairment Charges Trigger E&P Losses, While a Cash-Flow Crisis Looms you must be logged as a RBN Backstage Pass™ subscriber.
Full access to the RBN Energy blog archive which includes any posting more than 5 days old is available only to RBN Backstage Pass™ subscribers. In addition to blog archive access, RBN Backstage Pass™ resources include Drill-Down Reports, Spotlight Reports, Spotcheck Indicators, Market Fundamentals Webcasts, Get-Togethers and more. If you have already purchased a subscription, be sure you are logged in For additional help or information, contact us at firstname.lastname@example.org or 888-613-8874.